A Wasteful Use of Water

Help stop the Lake Powell Pipeline Project today.

The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission is beginning the public process and environmental analysis for the proposed Lake Powell Pipeline Project, which would pump water from Lake Powell 140 miles west to St. George, UT. Please take a moment to comment to this agency about your opposition to the project.

Comment to FERC by going to:
http://www.ferc.gov/docs-filing/ecomment.asp

Fill out the form, including your email. You will be emailed a link.
Open the link in the FERC email and use the Lake Powell Pipeline docket number to comment.

Docket # P-12966-001

Background:

The Lake Powell Pipeline is a proposed project by the Washington and Kane County Water Conservation Districts in Utah and sponsored by Utah’s Board of Water Resources to get 86,249 acre-feet of water to Southeastern Utah communities.

The 139 mile pipeline would run from Lake Powell to Sand Hollow Reservoir near St. George. The route is pictured below, but basically follows highway 89 except a divergence to skirt the Kaibab-Paiute Indian Reservation. Water would be pumped 50 miles uphill to a high point within the area of former Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument. After that, the water would flow down hill 90 miles through a series of six hydroelectric turbines. The power generated would partially offset the power needed for pumping. Power transmission lines, pump stations, and hydroelectric generators are a part of the proposal.

The project is conservatively expected to cost between $1.4 billion and 1.8 billion. The majority would have to be repaid by local water users of Kane and Washington County, which seems unfeasible based on an economic analysis by the University of Utah.

St. George residents use 294 gallons of water per person per day, roughly twice what people in Phoenix, Albuquerque, and Denver use. Conservation and local water development could play a major role in future growth instead of the pipeline.

Climate change is expected to have a negative impact on stream flows in the Colorado River Basin. This is well accepted in the scientific community. How much of a decrease is more uncertain, but if we look at a temperature increase alone (not counting probable precipitation decreases) we can expect to see a 10%-30% decrease in river flows at Lee’s Ferry by mid century. We all know that there are more “paper” rights in the river than actually exist, future shortages and more development will make the situation even worse. The Lake Powell Pipeline has 1957 water rights that are subordinate to the Central Utah Project and to Uintah and Duchesne County Water Conservation Districts (where potential oil shale, tar sands mining, and fracking operations compete with water use). In all likelihood, the Lake Powell Pipeline will not be able to deliver the full 86,000 acre feet per year to Southwestern Utah, making it a colossal waste of tax payer money and a huge burden on the water users of that district.

Also, Utah’s share of water from the Colorado River  includes water that the tribes of Utah are entitled to, but haven’t received. Water rights for the tribes in Utah, most of which have been not been quantified thus far, are based on the date the reservations were created. The State of Utah and Bureau of Reclamation have not helped fulfill these obligations to any of the tribes of Utah. The Lake Powell Pipeline should not be given State financing and priority over potential tribal water projects.

The Future:

We need to participate in the public process to stop this major water withdrawal from happening.

A public comment window is now open until November 19th. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) is lead agency in developing the Environmental Impact Statement for this project as required by NEPA. The comment period will be followed by a 45-day FERC response period that ends Jan. 3, 2019. Then, the drafting of the Environmental Impact Study (EIS) begins.  Many steps remain, with at least one more public comment period on the Draft EIS.

Permitting Process:
The Utah Board of Water Resources will construct, own, operate, and maintain the project. The Utah Division of Water Resources is working to support the Board of Water Resources through the process.

  • FERC works with the cooperating agencies to prepare a Draft Environmental Impact Statement (2019)
  • The U.S. Bureau of Reclamation negotiates an exchange contract with the state of Utah (ongoing)
  •  FERC seeks input on the Draft EIS from the public, non-governmental organizations, Indian tribes and agencies
  • FERC and other federal agencies issue an EIS that discloses environmental impacts and conditions required for approval
  • The cooperating agencies will issue individual records of decision and other authorizations (National Park Service, Bureau of Land Management, Bureau of Reclamation, Kaibab Band of Paiute Indians)

How to Comment:

Comment to FERC (Federal Energy Regulatory Commission)  by going to:
http://www.ferc.gov/docs-filing/ecomment.asp

Fill out the form, including your email. You will be emailed a link.
Open the link in the FERC email and use the Lake Powell Pipeline docket number to comment.
Docket # P-12966-001

MORE INFORMATION:

Higher Resolution Map of the Lake Powell Pipeline Route
Really cool interactive exploration of drought on the Colorado River
Living Rivers archive of information about the pipeline and water rights
Check out Conserve SW Utah for more information
Check out this scientific article about climate change on the Colorado River Basin
LPPutah.org The project described by its creators. Great reference for process, timeline, and agencies involved.